• Latest
  • Trending

Good News, Bad News, and Exploding Myths

September 17, 2008
My Story

My Story

July 12, 2025
Doing Better Next School Year

Doing Better Next School Year

July 10, 2025
Bring Harmony to Your Classroom

Bring Harmony to Your Classroom

July 10, 2025
Composing for Middle and High School Choirs – A conversation with Laura Farnell and Reginald Writer – Part 1

How Choir Practice Builds Confidence in Middle School Students

July 5, 2025
I Love ASTA!

I Love ASTA!

July 3, 2025
Technology: DAW Bundles

Features You Must Have in a Small Portable USB Audio Interface!

June 28, 2025
Choosing the Right Microphone(s) to Record Your Choral Rehearsal

Choosing the Right Microphone(s) to Record Your Choral Rehearsal

June 28, 2025
Best Budget Microphones for High School Podcasting

Best Budget Microphones for High School Podcasting

June 30, 2025
The Midwest Clinic Announces 2025 Clinicians and Performers

The Midwest Clinic Announces 2025 Clinicians and Performers

June 28, 2025
Running the Race

Running the Race

June 26, 2025
Sharpening the Tools in Your Toolkit

Sharpening the Tools in Your Toolkit

June 24, 2025
Treat Your Ears to Recordings of Upcoming Jazz Charts

Treat Your Ears to Recordings of Upcoming Jazz Charts

June 24, 2025
Sunday, July 13, 2025
  • Contact
SBO+
  • Departments
    • Concert Band
    • Orchestra
      • String Section
    • Choral
    • Marching Band
    • Jazz
    • Modern Band/Popular Music
      • Mariachi
    • Theater
    • Editorial
      • Upclose
      • Advocacy
        • NAfME Neighborhood
        • MAC Corner
        • MusicEd: Mentor Minute
      • Commentary
        • Bubbett’s Bookshelf
        • Leadership Tips
        • Perspective
        • InService
          • America’s Bandmasters
          • America’s Musicians
        • Tone Deaf Comics
      • Features
    • News
      • Headlines
      • New Products
    • Performance
      • Woodwinds
        • Wind Talkers
      • Percussion
        • GoodVibes
      • Repertoire
      • Playing Tips
    • Technology
    • Travel/Festivals
      • Fundraising
  • Current Issue
    • Past Issues
  • Awards/Entries
    • Teachers’ Choice Awards
    • 50 Teachers Who Make a Difference
  • Subscribe to SBO+
    • Subscribe
    • Login/Manage Subscription
    • Support
  • Advertise
    • Email PR!
No Result
View All Result
  • Departments
    • Concert Band
    • Orchestra
      • String Section
    • Choral
    • Marching Band
    • Jazz
    • Modern Band/Popular Music
      • Mariachi
    • Theater
    • Editorial
      • Upclose
      • Advocacy
        • NAfME Neighborhood
        • MAC Corner
        • MusicEd: Mentor Minute
      • Commentary
        • Bubbett’s Bookshelf
        • Leadership Tips
        • Perspective
        • InService
          • America’s Bandmasters
          • America’s Musicians
        • Tone Deaf Comics
      • Features
    • News
      • Headlines
      • New Products
    • Performance
      • Woodwinds
        • Wind Talkers
      • Percussion
        • GoodVibes
      • Repertoire
      • Playing Tips
    • Technology
    • Travel/Festivals
      • Fundraising
  • Current Issue
    • Past Issues
  • Awards/Entries
    • Teachers’ Choice Awards
    • 50 Teachers Who Make a Difference
  • Subscribe to SBO+
    • Subscribe
    • Login/Manage Subscription
    • Support
  • Advertise
    • Email PR!
No Result
View All Result
SBO+
No Result
View All Result

Good News, Bad News, and Exploding Myths

September 17, 2008
in Archives
Share on Facebook
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

One of the great aspects of what I do is my role as private investigator I mean, researcher. For the better part of my career I have been in a constant search for information that might provide a true picture of what is happening in our public schools. The data I found led me to author our first report, The Sound of Silence: The Unprecedented Decline of Music Education in California Public Schools. The impact of this report it was the catalyst that lead the state of California to invest more than three-quarters of a billion dollars over the past three years to restore music programs convinced us that we were on the right track (see SBO August, 2006).

We followed the Sound of Silence with legislative work in Arkansas to help mandate music and art for every child (see SBO March, 2005). This was followed by last year’s groundbreaking report for the state of New Jersey, Within Our Power: The Progress, Plight and Promise of Arts Education for Every Child. This was the first ever look at the status of arts education for every child measured in every school in the state. One of the actions taken as a result of this report included New Jersey becoming the first state in the nation to include the arts in district level accountability measure compliance with state policies. The first state ever (see SBO October, 2007).

Which brings me to our latest work, Arts Education in Wisconsin Public Schools: A Preliminary Review, which was commissioned by Arts Wisconsin, the state’s arts service, advocacy, and development organization, and the Wisconsin Alliance for Arts Education, the statewide organization dedicated to arts education. The report was analyzed and prepared by Music for All (with yours truly as the lead author). It provides the first detailed research conducted on the state of arts education in Wisconsin and was released a few weeks ago at a special statewide meeting.

The research of this latest study shows that while music and art are nearly universally available in most Wisconsin school districts serving grades 6-12, there has been a 5 percent decline in overall student participation during the past four years, creating cause for concern. The report also noted that most students are afforded no opportunities to learn dance or theater.

In what I term a “surprising finding,” the report also notes now pay attention to this the more rural a community, the higher the levels of student involvement in music and art. That’s right. Rural communities had a higher percentage of students enrolled in music and art than more urban schools. The more rural a community, the higher these numbers went. At the same time, the more rural a community was, the more favorable the ratio of students to arts teachers (a low student/arts teacher ratio is preferable) was, as well.

In addition, the affluence of a community appeared to have little or no influence on the percentage of student enrollment in arts education. If anything, on some measures there was a more favorable trend for less affluent communities than in the more affluent communities. That’s right, community wealth has no impact on the status of arts programs!

What Does it All Mean?
Well, there is good news and bad news. The good news is that music and art, at least from a district perspective, are widely available to students. The bad news is that the recent decline in student participation in all music and art deserves greater scrutiny and are cause for concern.

More importantly some key myths (and some excuses administrators use to justify the reduction or elimination of programs) have been burst, including:

  1. The wealth of a community has no impact on the existence or status of arts programs. This showed up in New Jersey. It showed up in Wisconsin and it is showing up in other states where we are currently working.
  2. The more rural a community the more students are involved in the arts programs. This may be something that is limited to the Midwest. However it has shown up enough for us to say administrators in rural communities cannot hide behind “being rural” as a justification for limited or no programs.

As saying goes, sacred cows make the best hamburgers! These are two sacred cows often used to defend cutting programs that we are happy to throw on the barbeque.

So with the above as an abbreviated summary, following are the key findings.

Grades 6-8 Overview
Most students in district grades 6-8 have access to art courses and participation is high. 96 percent of all students in district grades 6-8 have access to art courses. 75 percent of all students in this grade range across the state are enrolled in art programs. That said, the course offerings actually provided are limited.

Music in district grades 6-8 shows a similar level of access and participation. Music courses are offered by 97.4 percent of all school districts, representing 99 percent of statewide student enrollment. Of all students with access to programs, 89 percent participate in music. Concert Band, General Music and Chorus are the main courses with student participation. However, the percentage of student enrollment in Music declines significantly between the 6th and 9th grades.

Dance and Theater, except in rare instances, are not available in District Grades 6-8. Where Dance is available, student participation at the middle school level is higher than in Theater.

Grades 9-12 Overview
Art education in District Grades 9-12 shows both a depth of program and diversity of offerings available to most students. All school districts serving grades 9-12 report offering courses in art. There are 139,227 students enrolled in art courses at this level representing 47.66 percent of students. General Art/Design, Two Dimensional Art and Three Dimensional Art have the most student participation.

Access to music courses in District Grades 9-12 is nearly universal. However, student participation levels continue to decline. In this grade range, 98.8 percent of all students have access to music programs, yet, only 34 percent of all students (100,417) are enrolled. The decline in the percentage of student participation between the 9th and 12th grades is 23 percent. The programs with the highest percentage of student enrollment are Concert Band, Choir, and Chorus.

Theater, while more present than in district grades 6-8, involves less than 5 percent of all students in district grades 9-12 across the state. Only 19.2 percent of all students have access to Dance mostly in more urban districts and only 1 percent of students participate.

Percentage of Student Enrollment

A key indicator of quality arts programs is the percentage of student enrollment (the number of students enrolled in an arts course as a percentage of the total student population of the measured grades). This preliminary review found that the percentage of student enrollment in arts courses (Music and Art) is lower in urban areas (as defined by the National Center for Education Statistics and the Census Bureau) and higher in the more rural parts of the state. A higher percentage of student enrollment is preferable.

Student/Teacher Ratios
A similar finding was discovered when exploring the student/arts teacher ratio (the number of students in a district divided by the number of teacher assignments in the arts). Once again urban communities had a higher student/arts teacher ratio (more students per teacher) and the more rural communities had a lower student/arts teacher ratio. A lower ratio is preferable.

Community Wealth Index
Community affluence appears to have little or no influence on the percentage of student enrollment in arts education. The one surprising finding is that less affluent communities show higher participation in Art. Likewise surprising is a correlation between student/arts teacher ratio and the affluence of a community. Districts with a lower Wealth Index have a more favorable (lower) ratio than the more affluent communities. Side note: why this correlation exists requires additional research.

Since this report is using District-level data it does not make any judgments about individual schools. Disparities between schools may be masked when data is aggregated at the District level (something we learned from our work in New Jersey). This is particularly important when looking at data from larger school districts. A more thorough review based on actual school-level information is required to provide insight into individual school performance.

Will Anything Change?
The most important news is that this report will be used to create change. The information will be useful to educators, arts leaders, elected officials and civic leaders in the development of policies and programs that enhance 21st-century education for all Wisconsin students. The research was presented to and will be used by the Wisconsin Task Force on Arts and Creativity in Education, chaired by Lt. Governor Barbara Lawton and state superintendent of Public Instruction Elizabeth Burmaster as they shape a new vision for creativity in the state.

The Lesson
The lesson here is this: the more we know about what is really happening in our schools, the better decisions our policy makers will make. This has, without exception, led to increased access to music and arts education.

Maybe it is time for you to demand the same kind of information be developed in your state and community. You will be glad you did!

To download the full report online, go to: www.musicforall.org/resources/advocacy/wisconsin/.

For more information about what’s happening in Wisconsin, contact Anne Katz, Executive Director, Arts Wisconsin, (608) 255-8316, or by e-mail at akatz@artswisconsin.org.

You may also like:

The 2014 Best Communities for Music Education SBO Presents The 19th Annual 50 Directors Who Make A Difference Report: 50 Directors 2012 ’50 Directors Who Make a Difference’ Report SBO Presents the 18th Annual 50 Directors Who Make A Difference Report
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

POPULAR STORY

  • 50 Music Teachers Who Make a Difference

    50 Music Teachers Who Make a Difference

    1356 shares
    Share 542 Tweet 339
  • When Selecting New Choral Music, Choose Success

    1293 shares
    Share 517 Tweet 323
  • Concert Band Set-up Fundamentals

    1093 shares
    Share 437 Tweet 273
  • The Immediate Threat to School Music Programs

    1008 shares
    Share 403 Tweet 252
  • TI:ME Announces Free PreSonus Revelator USB Microphone at 30th Anniversary Celebration at TMEA

    970 shares
    Share 388 Tweet 243
ADVERTISEMENT

SchoolMusic.Travel

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Northwest USA

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Northwest USA

Mountains, music, and vibrant cities — the Northwest offers unforgettable experiences for student groups. 🎷 1. Seattle, WA – Innovation Meets Inspiration • Why it’s…

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Northeast USA

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Northeast USA

From Broadway to Boston, the Northeast inspires music students with rich culture and iconic venues. From Broadway lights to historic concert halls, the Northeast is…

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Midwest USA

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Midwest USA

The Midwest is the heartbeat of America — and it beats in 4/4 time. The Midwest is the heartbeat of America — and it beats…

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations on the West Coast

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations on the West Coast

Coastlines, concert halls, and creativity — the West Coast delivers stunning performance opportunities. From iconic performance halls to scenic coastal venues, the West Coast offers…

Next Post

The Future of Music Technology: Web-Based Software

  • July 2025

    Articles | Digital Issue
  • June 2025

    Articles | Digital Issue
  • May 2025

    Articles | Digital Issue
  • April 2025

    Articles | Digital Issue
  • March 2025

    Articles | Digital Issue
© 2005 - 2025 artistpro, LLC
7012 City Center Way, Suite 207
Fairview, Tennessee 37062
(800) 682-8114

No Result
View All Result
  • Departments
    • Concert Band
    • Orchestra
      • String Section
    • Choral
    • Marching Band
    • Jazz
    • Modern Band/Popular Music
      • Mariachi
    • Theater
    • Editorial
      • Upclose
      • Advocacy
      • Commentary
      • Features
    • News
      • Headlines
      • New Products
    • Performance
      • Woodwinds
      • Percussion
      • Repertoire
      • Playing Tips
    • Technology
    • Travel/Festivals
      • Fundraising
  • Current Issue
    • Past Issues
  • Awards/Entries
    • Teachers’ Choice Awards
    • 50 Teachers Who Make a Difference
  • Subscribe to SBO+
    • Subscribe
    • Login/Manage Subscription
    • Support
  • Advertise
    • Email PR!

© 2005 - 2024 artistpro, LLC 7012 City Center Way, Suite 207 Fairview, Tennessee 37062 (800) 682-8114

Wenger EndurAd Promo