• Latest
  • Trending
Figure 1: Also known as the EQ frown.

Battling Choral Entropy

September 19, 2022
Doing Better Next School Year

Doing Better Next School Year

July 10, 2025
Bring Harmony to Your Classroom

Bring Harmony to Your Classroom

July 10, 2025
Composing for Middle and High School Choirs – A conversation with Laura Farnell and Reginald Writer – Part 1

How Choir Practice Builds Confidence in Middle School Students

July 5, 2025
I Love ASTA!

I Love ASTA!

July 3, 2025
Technology: DAW Bundles

Features You Must Have in a Small Portable USB Audio Interface!

June 28, 2025
Choosing the Right Microphone(s) to Record Your Choral Rehearsal

Choosing the Right Microphone(s) to Record Your Choral Rehearsal

June 28, 2025
Best Budget Microphones for High School Podcasting

Best Budget Microphones for High School Podcasting

June 30, 2025
The Midwest Clinic Announces 2025 Clinicians and Performers

The Midwest Clinic Announces 2025 Clinicians and Performers

June 28, 2025
Running the Race

Running the Race

June 26, 2025
Sharpening the Tools in Your Toolkit

Sharpening the Tools in Your Toolkit

June 24, 2025
Treat Your Ears to Recordings of Upcoming Jazz Charts

Treat Your Ears to Recordings of Upcoming Jazz Charts

June 24, 2025
Several Shades of Green: One Size Does Not Fit All

Several Shades of Green: One Size Does Not Fit All

June 24, 2025
Friday, July 11, 2025
  • Contact
SBO+
  • Departments
    • Choral
    • Concert Band
    • Editorial
      • Advocacy
      • Commentary
      • Features
      • InService
      • MAC Corner
      • MusicEd: Mentor Minute
      • Perspective
      • Upclose
    • Jazz
    • Marching Band
    • Modern Band
    • New Products
    • Orchestra
    • Performance
      • Wind Talkers
      • Percussion
      • GoodVibes
      • Repertoire
      • Playing Tips
    • Technology
    • Theater
    • Tone Deaf Comics
    • Travel/Festivals
      • Fundraising
  • Current Issue
    • Past Issues
  • Awards/Entries
    • Teachers’ Choice Awards
    • 50 Teachers Who Make a Difference
  • Subscribe to SBO+
    • Subscribe
    • Login/Manage Subscription
    • Support
  • Advertise
    • Email PR!
No Result
View All Result
  • Departments
    • Choral
    • Concert Band
    • Editorial
      • Advocacy
      • Commentary
      • Features
      • InService
      • MAC Corner
      • MusicEd: Mentor Minute
      • Perspective
      • Upclose
    • Jazz
    • Marching Band
    • Modern Band
    • New Products
    • Orchestra
    • Performance
      • Wind Talkers
      • Percussion
      • GoodVibes
      • Repertoire
      • Playing Tips
    • Technology
    • Theater
    • Tone Deaf Comics
    • Travel/Festivals
      • Fundraising
  • Current Issue
    • Past Issues
  • Awards/Entries
    • Teachers’ Choice Awards
    • 50 Teachers Who Make a Difference
  • Subscribe to SBO+
    • Subscribe
    • Login/Manage Subscription
    • Support
  • Advertise
    • Email PR!
No Result
View All Result
SBO+
No Result
View All Result

Battling Choral Entropy

September 19, 2022
in Archives, The Practical Conductor, Choral, October 2017
Figure 1: Also known as the EQ frown.
Share on Facebook
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

By Brody McDonald

Entropy (plural entropies)

1: a measure of the unavailable energy in a closed thermodynamic system that is also usually considered to be a measure of the system’s disorder, that is a property of the system’s state, and that varies directly with any reversible change in heat in the system and inversely with the temperature of the system; broadly :the degree of disorder or uncertainty in a system

2: the degradation of the matter and energy in the universe to an ultimate state of inert uniformity

b: a process of degradation or running down or a trend to disorder

3: chaos, disorganization, randomness

This issue I decided to address an aspect of choral directing that lives large in my day right now. It is the battle against choral entropy. Entropy refers to the eventual breakdown of systems over time, a leveling out of… everything. It is easily understood by visualizing a glass of ice cubes melting to become room temperature water. A hot cup of coffee, sitting right next to the glass of ice cubes, will also reach room temperature.

Do you feel the effects of entropy on your music? Do your dynamics slowly erode so that the fortes and pianos all merge into a non-stop mezzo-forte? Do your staccatos and legatos all end up being some bizarre quasi-marcato (or perhaps have no articulation at all)? Do your singers want to drift back from tall, structured vowel sounds to something more spread and speech-level? These things happen in my choirs most often in the beginning part of the year, until good habits are formed. Let’s talk about how to raise our singers’ awareness and strengthen good habits. My college choir director called it “the development of choral instincts.” It is a process through which we train singers to become aggressively engaged in rehearsal by teaching them how to make the best types of mistakes. Please keep in mind that this process is not a quick fix – it requires consistent reinforcement to develop awareness in the singers and a culture of action.

Step 1 – Set Goals

Of all the habits a choir singer should have, I believe the first (and most important) one is that of singing with intention. That is to say – singing on purpose, or singing with a goal in mind. This is opposed to the “just singing through it” mentality that pervades many choristers. I described in a previous article the value of IS vs. ISN’T, meaning it is faster and more consistent only to worry about what things ARE or SHOULD BE rather than what they aren’t. We could say “don’t stand with your feet together,” and “don’t stand with your legs crossed” and “don’t stand leaning on one leg,” or we could simply say “stand with your feet shoulder-width apart.” In order to impart exactly what the music IS, I strongly suggest vocal modeling. When we model for our students, we can demonstrate the appropriate dynamics, vowel sounds, diphthong turns, consonant treatments, tuning, tone, syllable stress, phrase shape, and more – all at the same time!

Students should not just watch your demonstration or listen to it, they should analyze it. Then, they should set to work, physically mimicking you to recreate the sound. Was your jaw dropped? Theirs should be, too. Was your face expressive? Theirs should be, too. Was your breathing low? Theirs should be, too. Remind them of all the components of the demonstration, help them listen for each aspect, and make sure they understand that they should actively feel themselves creating the sound. If they don’t constantly feel active, they are likely very close to speech, which leads to under-supported, non-structured sound. Our motto: “You don’t sing like you talk, and you don’t dance like you walk.”

Step 2 – Calibrate Your Singers

I help my singers calibrate themselves by playing “Goldilocks and the Three Bears.” Let’s say we are working on a concept in class. Perhaps I’m trying to get the choir to sing a tall AW vowel (as in the word TALL), but they continue to sing the vowel AH (as in FATHER). I start like this (try to see this in your mind): I hold my hands out in front of me, about three feet apart, as if to show I caught a really big fish or as if to offer up a bear hug. I shake one hand and say, “This is too cold.” Then I shake the other hand: “This is too hot. Come up here and show me… where is ‘just right?’” Without fail, a student volunteers, comes forward, and places one of their hands directly in the center of mine. I thank them and begin my speech.

“John has indicated that ‘just right’ is in the middle of ‘too hot’ and ‘too cold.’ Now, let’s take the example of Goldilocks and the porridge. What is porridge? It’s like oatmeal, sort of. What temperature is in the middle? Lukewarm. Does anybody in this room like to eat lukewarm oatmeal? I didn’t think so. Oatmeal is most often enjoyed hot. Not warm, not tepid – HOT. Just not TOO hot.”

This is how I think of it. There is a target we are trying to hit, an outcome we are trying to achieve. If we miss, we must miss the right way. In the case of singing an AW vowel, I feel that AW is closer to OH than it is to AH. It sure feels that way to me. Let’s visualize this on a number line.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

AH AW OH

When we are aiming at singing the AW vowel, what we see is that all mistakes are not created equal. Making an AW that is too round and dark begins to turn the vowel into OH. Keeping the vowel too bright leans towards AH – but at different distances. Because there is less room between AW and OH than there is between AW and AH, there are fewer wrong answers/mistakes to be made by “overshooting” in that direction.

I feel the same way about dynamics. See below:

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

mf f ff

I feel this way because I tend to think of mezzo-forte as “the volume that comes out without trying to be loud or soft.” I think forte should be significantly louder than mezzo-forte. It helps prevent entropy of dynamics. So forte in my mind is closer to fortissimo than to mezzo-forte. This mental calibration helps increase the odds of tangible results. If a song jumps from mf to f, and my singers overshoot mf to ff… the effect of getting louder has succeeded nonetheless. If, however, they jump from mf to “mf +”… well… perhaps the effect of getting louder is not noticed.

Whenever I ask my singers to fix something, I make them aware this phenomenon: there might be two sides to the target, but one side is a more correct wrong than the other. All of this calibration is designed to lead us into step 3.

Step 3 – Aim Small / Miss Small

“Aim small; miss small” is a common catchphrase among gun enthusiasts. The premise is that more specific aim leads to greater results. For instance, instead of thinking “I want to hit the target,” think “I want to hit the bullseye.” Instead of “I want to hit the door,” someone might think “I’m aiming at the knothole in the door” I’ve heard of people who think to the level of “I’m trying to hit that nail head.” I even read a story about a policeman who, in a shootout, ended up sending one of his bullets down the barrel of the criminal’s gun. He was aiming for the muzzle-hole to increase accuracy and succeeded.

When we look at the examples show again below (target vowel, dynamics) we begin to see what I mean by “aim small; miss small.” Some mistakes are better than others. If our target vowel is represented by 8, then aiming at the area between 8-10 is aiming small. That is to say, when trying to make a tall vowel, it is less damaging to be too tall than to not be tall enough. If we are increasing volume to forte, overshooting is a much better bet than undershooting.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

AH AW OH

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

mf f ff

Step 4 – Go for it!

At this point, I’ve encouraged you to:

1. Set the target by demonstrating for your singers

2. Calibrate your singers by showing them not all mistakes are equal

3. Encourage your singers to aim small – shooting very specifically for the smaller area where the “closest” mistakes live

Now we’re going to encourage huge action. Here are some mottos on which I rely daily. I can’t remember where I picked them up, but they aren’t mine.

“Often right, sometimes wrong, never in doubt.”

“Make it instant, and make it dramatic.”

And my favorite – which came from R.D. Mathey during my time at Bowling Green: “CIP – Consistency, Insistency, and Persistency.” By this he meant the director should be consistent in what they want from their singers. They should insist that the singing be as they want it. Because the first attempts are rarely correct, the director should persist until the result is what they desire.

Because the singers have been made aware of the goals, and also what mistakes are best, they should now swing for the fences. After all, operating in such an environment, how can they fail other than to not give great effort?

You may also like:

Default ThumbnailBetter Vocals in an Instant! SBO Presents the 21st Annual 50 Directors Who Make a Difference Default ThumbnailBehind the Adjudicator Table 50 Music Teachers Who Make a Difference The New York Philharmonic’s CONTACT! series at National Sawdust Photo: Chris LeeStart Your Season with Greater Awareness!
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

POPULAR STORY

  • 50 Music Teachers Who Make a Difference

    50 Music Teachers Who Make a Difference

    1356 shares
    Share 542 Tweet 339
  • When Selecting New Choral Music, Choose Success

    1293 shares
    Share 517 Tweet 323
  • Concert Band Set-up Fundamentals

    1093 shares
    Share 437 Tweet 273
  • The Immediate Threat to School Music Programs

    1008 shares
    Share 403 Tweet 252
  • TI:ME Announces Free PreSonus Revelator USB Microphone at 30th Anniversary Celebration at TMEA

    970 shares
    Share 388 Tweet 243
ADVERTISEMENT

SchoolMusic.Travel

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Northwest USA

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Northwest USA

Mountains, music, and vibrant cities — the Northwest offers unforgettable experiences for student groups. 🎷 1. Seattle, WA – Innovation Meets Inspiration • Why it’s…

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Northeast USA

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Northeast USA

From Broadway to Boston, the Northeast inspires music students with rich culture and iconic venues. From Broadway lights to historic concert halls, the Northeast is…

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Midwest USA

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Midwest USA

The Midwest is the heartbeat of America — and it beats in 4/4 time. The Midwest is the heartbeat of America — and it beats…

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations on the West Coast

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations on the West Coast

Coastlines, concert halls, and creativity — the West Coast delivers stunning performance opportunities. From iconic performance halls to scenic coastal venues, the West Coast offers…

Next Post
Figure 4

The Joy of Solfège

  • July 2025

    Articles | Digital Issue
  • June 2025

    Articles | Digital Issue
  • May 2025

    Articles | Digital Issue
  • April 2025

    Articles | Digital Issue
  • March 2025

    Articles | Digital Issue
© 2005 - 2025 artistpro, LLC
7012 City Center Way, Suite 207
Fairview, Tennessee 37062
(800) 682-8114

No Result
View All Result
  • Departments
    • Choral
    • Concert Band
    • Editorial
      • Advocacy
      • Commentary
      • Features
      • InService
      • MAC Corner
      • MusicEd: Mentor Minute
      • Perspective
      • Upclose
    • Jazz
    • Marching Band
    • Modern Band
    • New Products
    • Orchestra
    • Performance
      • Wind Talkers
      • Percussion
      • GoodVibes
      • Repertoire
      • Playing Tips
    • Technology
    • Theater
    • Tone Deaf Comics
    • Travel/Festivals
      • Fundraising
  • Current Issue
    • Past Issues
  • Awards/Entries
    • Teachers’ Choice Awards
    • 50 Teachers Who Make a Difference
  • Subscribe to SBO+
    • Subscribe
    • Login/Manage Subscription
    • Support
  • Advertise
    • Email PR!

© 2005 - 2024 artistpro, LLC 7012 City Center Way, Suite 207 Fairview, Tennessee 37062 (800) 682-8114

Wenger EndurAd Promo