• Latest
  • Trending
End Note: The Great Suzuki Debate

End Note: The Great Suzuki Debate

November 19, 2013
Videotaping Your Show

Videotaping Your Show

September 16, 2025
Tone Deaf

Tone Deaf

September 15, 2025
ADVERTISEMENT
Set the Stage for High Expectations on Day 1

Set the Stage for High Expectations on Day 1

September 12, 2025
Serving Others Through Music – Ryan’s Story

Serving Others Through Music – Ryan’s Story

September 11, 2025
Reflections

Reflections

September 11, 2025

LA County Secures Nearly $24 Million to Boost Life Sciences Sector, Create 10,000 Jobs

September 11, 2025
Headlines

Headlines

September 10, 2025
Blueprints and Building Blocks: Starting the Year with Intention

Blueprints and Building Blocks: Starting the Year with Intention

September 9, 2025
Here We Go Again

Here We Go Again

September 5, 2025

The 2026 YoungArts Application is Now Open!

September 5, 2025
Empowering Educators: Bridging the Gap Between Teaching and Technical Expertise in Music Education By Lisa Canning

Empowering Educators: Bridging the Gap Between Teaching and Technical Expertise in Music Education By Lisa Canning

August 26, 2025
How Your Music Boosters Can Help You Become a Better Teacher By Joel Schut & Katherine (Kip) Mason

How Your Music Boosters Can Help You Become a Better Teacher By Joel Schut & Katherine (Kip) Mason

August 22, 2025
Tuesday, September 16, 2025
  • Contact
SBO+
  • Departments
    • Concert Band
    • Orchestra
      • String Section
    • Choral
    • Marching Band
    • Jazz
    • Modern Band/Popular Music
      • Mariachi
    • Theater
    • Editorial
      • Upclose
      • Advocacy
        • NAfME Neighborhood
        • MAC Corner
        • MusicEd: Mentor Minute
      • Commentary
        • Bubbett’s Bookshelf
        • Leadership Tips
        • Perspective
        • InService
          • America’s Bandmasters
          • America’s Musicians
        • Tone Deaf Comics
      • Features
    • News
      • Headlines
      • New Products
    • Performance
      • Woodwinds
        • Wind Talkers
      • Percussion
        • GoodVibes
      • Repertoire
      • Playing Tips
    • Technology
    • Travel/Festivals
      • Fundraising
  • Current Issue
    • Past Issues
  • Awards/Entries
    • Teachers’ Choice Awards
    • 50 Teachers Who Make a Difference
  • Subscribe to SBO+
    • Subscribe
    • Login/Manage Subscription
    • Support
  • Advertise
    • Email PR!
No Result
View All Result
  • Departments
    • Concert Band
    • Orchestra
      • String Section
    • Choral
    • Marching Band
    • Jazz
    • Modern Band/Popular Music
      • Mariachi
    • Theater
    • Editorial
      • Upclose
      • Advocacy
        • NAfME Neighborhood
        • MAC Corner
        • MusicEd: Mentor Minute
      • Commentary
        • Bubbett’s Bookshelf
        • Leadership Tips
        • Perspective
        • InService
          • America’s Bandmasters
          • America’s Musicians
        • Tone Deaf Comics
      • Features
    • News
      • Headlines
      • New Products
    • Performance
      • Woodwinds
        • Wind Talkers
      • Percussion
        • GoodVibes
      • Repertoire
      • Playing Tips
    • Technology
    • Travel/Festivals
      • Fundraising
  • Current Issue
    • Past Issues
  • Awards/Entries
    • Teachers’ Choice Awards
    • 50 Teachers Who Make a Difference
  • Subscribe to SBO+
    • Subscribe
    • Login/Manage Subscription
    • Support
  • Advertise
    • Email PR!
No Result
View All Result
SBO+
No Result
View All Result

End Note: The Great Suzuki Debate

November 19, 2013
in Commentary
Share on Facebook
ADVERTISEMENT

Shinichi Suzuki
As SBO readers will have noticed by now, this publication recently began running a column, “String Section,” authored by renowned performer, clinician, and educator Mark O’Connor. While unquestionably one of the great innovators in string playing today, as well as an eloquent writer, O’Connor can be somewhat controversial, particularly regarding his unflagging criticism of the Suzuki method.

Hopefully some of the readers who responded to the String Section column’s debut with vitriol aimed at this publication will see that SBO has no interest in entangling itself in the debate about which instructional method is best – or worst, for that matter. SBO’s goal is to empower and support music educators through practical, accessible articles covering the array of topics that band and orchestra directors face throughout the school year. A discussion of the nature of string education, including how to prepare music students for success in a changing professional landscape, is relevant, but only in so far as it stays constructive. (And it bears mentioning that the String Section columns which have appeared in this publication have largely focused on positive examples of innovative performance and learning opportunities for young string players.)

My own view is that anything which fosters appreciation for music and encourages young music makers and parental involvement is a net positive. To those who would argue that point, it seems fairly obvious that the inevitable shortcomings of any method will be addressed by attentive educators, who continuously augment and tailor the latest books and pedagogy to their personal teaching philosophies and to meet their students’ needs.

While designed as an informative and relevant article on its own merits, the interview with Marilyn Kesler of the Suzuki Association of the Americas (SAA) was in part intended to give someone from within the Suzuki world a chance to respond directly to some of the criticisms that the popular string method has faced. Beyond chairing the Board of Directors for the SAA, Kesler has been a champion of music education for nearly a half a century. “Mama K,” as she was affectionately referred to by her students, retired from the Michigan Public Schools several years ago after 42 years in the classroom.

In the course of that interview, I couldn’t help but notice a parallel between something she said and some comments made by Tony Cox of Mt. Juliet High School in the November issue’s cover feature. Discussing the development of a band program capable of fitting in with other elite groups on the national stage, Tony mentions a “triad” of critical parts: “If you’re going to try to compete at the national level, it has to be a collective effort between the band parents, the kids, and the staff – it can’t be something that is just motivated by one part of that triad.” Cox goes on to say, “I don’t know how in the world we could do what we do without the parental support that we have. It would be impossible.”

Kesler, meanwhile, also spoke about the essential role played by parents in the process of teaching kids music, lauding their participation as one of the core elements that has made the Suzuki method so popular. “When teaching very young children, you must involve the parents,” she says. “The triangle between parent, child, and teacher develops strong bonds.” Later, Kesler mirrors Cox’s statement, noting: “Most music departments would not be able to function without parent support.”

Shin’ichi Suzuki did not invent the concept of parental involvement in a child’s music education, but that’s one facet of his educational philosophy that he most certainly got right.

You may also like:

Vote Now for 2014 Best Tools for Schools SBO Presents The 19th Annual 50 Directors Who Make A Difference 2012 ’50 Directors Who Make a Difference’ Report Default Thumbnail2011 ’50 Directors Who Make a Difference’ Report The 23rd 50 Directors Who Make a Difference Report
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

POPULAR STORY

  • 50 Music Teachers Who Make a Difference

    50 Music Teachers Who Make a Difference

    1369 shares
    Share 548 Tweet 342
  • When Selecting New Choral Music, Choose Success

    1296 shares
    Share 518 Tweet 324
  • Concert Band Set-up Fundamentals

    1111 shares
    Share 444 Tweet 278
  • The Immediate Threat to School Music Programs

    1013 shares
    Share 405 Tweet 253
  • TI:ME Announces Free PreSonus Revelator USB Microphone at 30th Anniversary Celebration at TMEA

    971 shares
    Share 388 Tweet 243
ADVERTISEMENT

SchoolMusic.Travel

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Northwest USA

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Northwest USA

Mountains, music, and vibrant cities — the Northwest offers unforgettable experiences for student groups. 🎷 1. Seattle, WA – Innovation Meets Inspiration• Why it’s great:…

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Northeast USA

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Northeast USA

From Broadway to Boston, the Northeast inspires music students with rich culture and iconic venues. From Broadway lights to historic concert halls, the Northeast is…

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Midwest USA

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations in the Midwest USA

The Midwest is the heartbeat of America — and it beats in 4/4 time. The Midwest is the heartbeat of America — and it beats…

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations on the West Coast

Top 10 School Music Travel Destinations on the West Coast

Coastlines, concert halls, and creativity — the West Coast delivers stunning performance opportunities. From iconic performance halls to scenic coastal venues, the West Coast offers…

Next Post

2013 BOA Grand National Championships

  • September 2025

    Articles | Digital Issue
  • August 2025

    Articles | Digital Issue
  • July 2025

    Articles | Digital Issue
  • June 2025

    Articles | Digital Issue
  • May 2025

    Articles | Digital Issue
© 2005 - 2025 artistpro, LLC
7012 City Center Way, Suite 207
Fairview, Tennessee 37062
(800) 682-8114

No Result
View All Result
  • Departments
    • Concert Band
    • Orchestra
      • String Section
    • Choral
    • Marching Band
    • Jazz
    • Modern Band/Popular Music
      • Mariachi
    • Theater
    • Editorial
      • Upclose
      • Advocacy
      • Commentary
      • Features
    • News
      • Headlines
      • New Products
    • Performance
      • Woodwinds
      • Percussion
      • Repertoire
      • Playing Tips
    • Technology
    • Travel/Festivals
      • Fundraising
  • Current Issue
    • Past Issues
  • Awards/Entries
    • Teachers’ Choice Awards
    • 50 Teachers Who Make a Difference
  • Subscribe to SBO+
    • Subscribe
    • Login/Manage Subscription
    • Support
  • Advertise
    • Email PR!

© 2005 - 2024 artistpro, LLC 7012 City Center Way, Suite 207 Fairview, Tennessee 37062 (800) 682-8114